Jerry Christmas: Oy Vey
![]()
No, not that Jerry.
I traveled up to Vassar College to see Jerry Christmas, one of the offerings from New York Stage & Film this year. Stage & Film has had a lot of transfers in recent years, and this was one of the most buzzed-about shows of the season, so I was pretty pumped to see this new Andrew Lippa/Daniel Goldfarb musical.
The show was a fun romp through super-Jew-land, but ultimately I found it sadly underwhelming. The cast was excellent, especially Leslie Kritzer, David Reiser, and Adriane Lenox, but the show just feels flat, doesn't really hit its marks, and never becomes three-dimensional. With a heaping portion of yiddish jokes and torah humor, the comedic element is solidly in place, but after a while the repetition of this one topic wears thin and becomes obvious, and it's plain to see that the show is really missing a heart behind the humor.
The tuner is basically about Jerry Barron, a failed film star of the 60's who has been pegged as too "jewey" and too different, who attempts to make his big comeback on a live televised christmas special, sacrificing his (and his family's) religion and identity. Unfortunately, Jerry is a narcissist of epic proportions, and it's impossible to root for him. Without a sympathetic main character, the show lacks any heart. I'd say with a rewrite that adds more characters to make the stories more three-dimensional, and changing Jerry's wife into a real brass-tacks Jewish mother with a strong backbone and a big heart, the show could really take off.

