Caught Love Sucks at NYMF last night - opening night! In the past, you may have heard Moxie griping about how everything sucks at NYMF, not just love, but I'll try to restrain myself today, because this was one of the better shows I've seen in the festival, past years or present.
Love Sucks is a punk rock musical retelling of Love's Labors Lost. Despite said description, it is an enjoyable evening of theater! The plot is one of those Shakespeare retellings that translates wonkily into the 1970's East Village - two dueling punk bands, one all-male and the other all-female, compete for label attention, even as their members secretly fall in love across forbidden band lines. There's the prerequisite couple who are so quarrelsome that they have to be tricked into falling for each other, which means some really goofy and far-fetched scenes centered around the old "Hey, did you hear that Patti likes Big Joe? Well she does, she's just too afraid to say so!"

The marvel of Love Sucks is that they've got three cast members who manage to make it all come off as an actual gritty, rocking show with some real teeth and edge. Rebecca Hart and Nicholas Webber play the lead singers who hate each other until they realize they loourve each other, and they both are totally believable not only as rockers, but as characters who have such an axe to grind, "nobody would ever date them more than three times" (except each other, 'natch). Nicholas Webber makes angsty sad-sack Big Joe cute and relatable. Rebecca Hart's incredibly dry humor and surgically-precise timing manages to make a joke involving "l'enfant terrible of punk rock" really funny. Definitely a feat to be respected. Both Nicholas and Rebecca totally rock, and make the show fun and involving.
And Heather Robb, my own good friend and personal hero, exudes charm and rock and, uh, SEX appeal! Hey Heather - where have you been storing all that crazy, floor-humping, bang-a-different-guy-each-night-and-LOVE-it crazy charisma? Heather also is a fantastic actress, which is more than evident in her performance as the keyboard player who parties with a different guy each night, until she meets rocker dude from the other band, who melts her with a glance. In an extended "hey, love is awesome!" scene set in Thompkins Square Park, her and her corresponding dude rocker discover that they've both written songs about each other, and serenade each other in gorgeous harmony. And she's so good, not a single audience member puked - I swear!
The three performers also have some of the most uniquely awesome voices I've heard in a musical in ages, which gives some much-needed street cred to a musical that would otherwise have actual punk rockers rolling in their graves. I mean the two forms haven't exactly been BFF in the past, and I doubt the ladies of Bikini Kill put much stock in Rodgers & Hart.
The inevitable question that hovers around NYMF shows is "will it transfer?" I think this one actually could have a shot. Right now, the kick-ass performances are keeping the show afloat. The creators need to do some serious work on re-tooling the book so it makes more sense and is a little less frivolous under the guise of coming from Shakespeare. They also need to work on the songs, because most of them sound identical. But given some attention in the right areas from the right people, Love Sucks could be a nice little punky off-broadway show.